[NEW MILLETIANS] Please note that all new forum users have to be approved before posting. This process can take up to 24 hours, and we appreciate your patience.
If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the
Nexon Forums Code of Conduct. You have to register before you can post, so you can log in or create a forum name above to proceed. Thank you for your visit!
Is it ever explained why...
...only elves seem to be cursed to eventually become monsters? It seems strange that the Irinid placed an additional curse (on top of cursing Connous and Physis into inhospitable wastelands) on them, but not do the same to the giants, since they were just as guilty of abusing her gifts out of greed as the elves were.
(Unless they were and we just were never told, for whatever reason. Maybe the Bandersnatches in Par Ruins were cursed giants?)
Thoughts or theories?
Comments
(Note: Milletian Elves and Milletian Giants are not affected by the curses.)
In the case of the Elves:
First, their homeland Connous, which used to be a luscious forest, was turned into a lethal, barren desert.
Second, they were granted immortality in the form of the desert curse; Connous Elves do not die.
Castanea chose to grant her people oblivion by forbidding the knowledge of the curse from ever reaching her people. She used the Memory Tower to control what her people learned, and would personally destroy the memories or even a person who became knowledgable or overly curious about Irinid's Curse.
When a Connous Elf 'dies', their bodies are traditionally taken out into Longa Desert and are given a sky burial (their bodies are left to decompose exposed to the elements and wild animals), and are eventually consumed by the shifting dunes.
Of course, that's a good way to explain how an elf's body vanishes when they eventually transmogrify and reanimate...
Castanea believes that protecting her people from the knowledge of their 'immortality' and controlling their memories as a sort of collective conscience allows her people to live happier lives, and she is very cold towards outsiders and those who mingle outside of the 'safety' of Filia.
Some Elves expressed discontent with that way of living. Since Saga/G18, the Memory Tower has been destroyed, but Castanea is still very hesitant to allow outsiders into the village (which is why the Commerce Outpost is located so far outside of town.)
In the case of Giants:
First, their homeland, which was once a forest and prairie, was turned into a lethal, frozen wasteland.
Second, Physis Giants cannot forget, in stark contrast to 'the oblivious Elves'.
(I don't recall if this is part of the curse or a simple fact of the species, but I think its part of the curse...?)
When compared to the Elves, Giants seem to have it better. A perfect memory sounds useful, no?
However, it isn't possible for any Giant to move forward. Their past stays with them - they cannot let it go. In the context of war, that's pretty horrific, even if self inflicted. Combined with their shorter life spans, Physis Giants effectively created a society where generational grudges and prejudice form the political backbone of the race. The in-fighting and hate and prejudice is effectively destroying Vales from the inside.
King Sharpe, the previous King of the Giants, was assassinated because he desired to end the war against the elves, which directly opposed the Seebarsch family's desire for more war, and was seen as an insult to the previous King; Krug's father.
Giants accused of treasonous intent are seen being dragged away by the Black Ravens, never to be seen again.
'Weak' Giants are forced out, due to how much value Giant society places upon being 'strong', while Giants in power turn a blind eye to it, just to save face.
They don't need much more than that to doom themselves.
There are definitely holes in the lore, but most of what I've said is actually stuff that can be found in optional dialogues hidden amongst the NPCs. Giants, unfortunately, seemed to be quite rushed during G6 and G7, so they all come across as quite shallow characters.
Longa Dungeon has strong relevance to their history as well. Look at the walls and you can see giants and their hands and knees to some shadowy looking figure and faded giant beasts above the giants (sort of looks like a giant stone statue flexing). For the elves you see them on their knees begging or worshipping a blue figure with white swirls that look like air currents above them. This shows that Longa holds some recorded history linked to their unique Beast and Falcon Transformations.