Check out all of the details of this month's Patch Notes, featuring the March Quality of Life Update! https://mabinogi.nexon.net/news/81261/march-quality-of-life-updates
[NEW MILLETIANS] Please note that all new forum users have to be approved before posting. This process can take up to 24 hours, and we appreciate your patience.
If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the Nexon Forums Code of Conduct. You have to register before you can post, so you can log in or create a forum name above to proceed. Thank you for your visit!

What would you do if . . .

HelsaHelsa
Mabinogi Rep: 22,745
Posts: 5,422
Member
edited June 10, 2020 in Feedback and Suggestions
. . . you were made Project Director of Mabinogi: World-Wide?

Comments

  • GypsySpiritGypsySpirit
    Mabinogi Rep: 2,340
    Posts: 270
    Member
    I don't know if this counts but maybe push out 2 new pets a year that can be bought directly like they used to. Of course there's the holiday sale but no pet gacha.
  • CrimsọnCrimsọn
    Mabinogi Rep: 64,395
    Posts: 8,892
    Member
    Bring shop bags back for NEW STUFF and not try to appease the masses by bringing shop bags back with old excrement.
  • JJJJ
    Mabinogi Rep: 5,400
    Posts: 500
    Member
    Bring back the EU servers. I miss having low latency. Also hire staff to manage them with a routine of maintenance at least every week.
    Party PvP was fun, why does it not exist in any other regions?
  • NegumikoNegumiko
    Mabinogi Rep: 9,375
    Posts: 1,249
    Member
    less gacha and more outfit bags. as for in game stuff more Iria content like Elf and Giant marriage, Iria Commerce, revamp taming, more adventure seals quests with a improved adventure seal shop, and more Iria events.
    JJWolfsingerSherriIyasenucourtneyyKalulah
  • КалашниковКалашников
    Mabinogi Rep: 3,300
    Posts: 274
    Member
    edited June 9, 2020
    Make older life skills a little more competitive with magic craft & engineering, in regards to selling. Revert dungeon system.

    Also, not to make so many title coupons, enchants gacha-only. Especially not gacha from crossover event we'll never see again.

    *I'm not sure what Project Director does exactly.
  • HabimaruHabimaru
    Mabinogi Rep: 3,430
    Posts: 760
    Member
    Short Answer : You would obviously promote, Promote, PROMOTE, and also, develop, Develop, DEVELOP!

    There are otherwise a lot of things I would do with it which would take up a LOT of my time/energy but I won't mention every detail right now.

    One of the things that is sorely needed is to get rid of the Garrison-Role from Black/White Dragon-Raids or to change its parameters.
    Ever gotten the Garrison-Role as an Elf ? Your Smash-Delays gimp you even further than the already LOW STR of an Elf.

    One of the many things that I will mention for now is that I'd expand Fusion-Bolt into an Advanced-Magic Version.
    Basically, you would be able to Fusion-Cast Fire-Ball with Ice-Spear, Fire-Ball with Thunder, Ice-Spear with Thunder, Fire-Ball with Thunder, etc.
    As of right now I don't see any Dan-Test Options for Fusion-Bolt so it could perhaps be slotted there in order to Unlock said Extension/Expansion.

    I suppose I'll just mention one other thing I'd do with magic : Pair/Group-Casting (two or more people casting spells together for amplified effect).
    Sebastian
  • CrimsọnCrimsọn
    Mabinogi Rep: 64,395
    Posts: 8,892
    Member
    edited June 9, 2020
    Negumiko wrote: »
    less gacha and more outfit bags. as for in game stuff more Iria content like Elf and Giant marriage, Iria Commerce, revamp taming, more adventure seals quests with a improved adventure seal shop, and more Iria events.

    NEW outfit bags. You gotta specify that or else they will keep releasing the old ones. It's disappointing as hell when they announce that they are going to put outfit bags on sale and it's just old junk. What's worse is I really believe that they think they are appeasing us by doing that. Well Nexon, just letting you know that we're not impressed.

    Also a new talent every year would be awesome. Try implementing some of our talent ideas and release a new talent every year to keep us busy with something else besides rehashed events. WE'RE BORED and that's BAD.
    Wolfsinger
  • KensamaofmariKensamaofmari
    Mabinogi Rep: 34,700
    Posts: 7,902
    Member
    Helsa wrote: »
    . . . you were made Project Director of Mabinogi: World-Wide?

    It depends on what duties and responsibilities that the project director has.
    courtneyyWolfsinger
  • LeineiLeinei
    Mabinogi Rep: 16,240
    Posts: 2,468
    Member
    Oh, crap. That's a long list.

    1) Overhaul the Cash Shop.
    -Gacha with new outfits would be fine, but then after a month, outfits from said gacha would be given bags and charged accordingly (as well as if they have an animation).
    -Add 1-Day Skill Training Potions of all varieties, including Crusader Skills. The grind is real, folks, and those ten minute potions don't cut it anymore.
    -All Pets in Cash Shop (none of that gacha bonus stuff)
    -Sky's Stars would be a constant thing. Each week would be a stars special, but if no new items were released, they would be attributed to Eweca Orbs.
    -Simon's Bag and Luxury Equipment Bags always available.
    -Mabinogi Merchandise FTW

    2) Update All Older Traits/Outfits. I'm looking at you, low polygon hairstyles.

    3) Update All NPCs to consistent graphics. Best example is Glenis right next to Blaanid. The difference is STARK. Maybe if it's possible, go back and update the graphics of all the generations, at least character wise.

    4) Make the Lia Fall appear in the cut scene where Millia is floating in the air during Saga, or am I the only one who gets this?

    5) Narrowing the range of stats given to weapons/armor/accessories for your rank in a skill where stats are random. Basically, for Magic Craft/Engineering/Blacksmithing, each rank narrows point range of the resulting item. Players who rank the above skills to Dan 3 or Mastering them should not have to worry about getting the LOWEST possible result when creating an item when you're Dan 3 Mastered. The resulting point range should give you 95-100% stats at that point. It's absurd that stats are RANDOM. I'm Dan 3 Mastered in Magic Craft and Engie and it drives me BONKERS when the stats aren't high given all the work I put into get those up.

    6) Keep the current writer and give them a raise.
    SherriIyasenuWolfsingerGypsySpiritCrimsọnKalulah
  • IyasenuIyasenu
    Mabinogi Rep: 24,265
    Posts: 2,887
    Member
    Every Wednesday would be Free Ice Cream Day.

    Ha, but seriously, I dunno.
    World-wide? I don't know even enough about the other regions' versions of Mabi.
    So I guess first thing first would be to get in the know.

    Well maybe... I know if just one thing, I'd like to change Dan test's to have their training counts uncapped, so a person could still rank up with say, 2 SS's but would also be able to pass with like 8 As.
    I'd say a week and some change for Magnum Dan 2 to 3 beats never being able to get there ever.
    Pardon the "weenie-fication" if you will, but pass-failing is just my least favorite thing, maybe next to gathering Briogh Crystals since I have no fun doing any of the Tech Duinn missions.

    But otherwise... well, there are some interesting ideas over in the Feedback section.
    A talent for scythes sounds pretty nifty, and that's been suggested there at least a handful of times.

    There's also the fact that Eiren's an Ace, but has no Ace Talent associated with her.
    She only uses Chains, so I wonder what the others would be.
    Plus there's the over-representation of certain talents in Ace talents, like Cleric and Apothecary, whereas none of the Aces currently have Archery or Knight, for example.
    Though making up new Ace talents would probably require making up new Aces, and since they're part of the storyline, that'd complicate things.
    Or maybe make a new special talent category separate from Aces yet similar in function. As neat as the Aces are, a new organization of special NPCs would probably be cool. Though I feel like I'd be designing them based on what talents they could cover, before any actual characterization and plot usefulness.

    Well, this kind of stuff is fun to think about if anything, but I don't really have any grand ideas.
    Kalulah
  • SherriSherri
    Mabinogi Rep: 18,570
    Posts: 2,809
    Member
    edited June 9, 2020
    Leinei wrote: »
    Oh, crap. That's a long list.

    1) Overhaul the Cash Shop.
    -Gacha with new outfits would be fine, but then after a month, outfits from said gacha would be given bags and charged accordingly (as well as if they have an animation).
    -Add 1-Day Skill Training Potions of all varieties, including Crusader Skills. The grind is real, folks, and those ten minute potions don't cut it anymore.
    -All Pets in Cash Shop (none of that gacha bonus stuff)
    -Sky's Stars would be a constant thing. Each week would be a stars special, but if no new items were released, they would be attributed to Eweca Orbs.
    -Simon's Bag and Luxury Equipment Bags always available.
    -Mabinogi Merchandise FTW

    2) Update All Older Traits/Outfits. I'm looking at you, low polygon hairstyles.

    3) Update All NPCs to consistent graphics. Best example is Glenis right next to Blaanid. The difference is STARK. Maybe if it's possible, go back and update the graphics of all the generations, at least character wise.

    4) Make the Lia Fall appear in the cut scene where Millia is floating in the air during Saga, or am I the only one who gets this?

    5) Narrowing the range of stats given to weapons/armor/accessories for your rank in a skill where stats are random. Basically, for Magic Craft/Engineering/Blacksmithing, each rank narrows point range of the resulting item. Players who rank the above skills to Dan 3 or Mastering them should not have to worry about getting the LOWEST possible result when creating an item when you're Dan 3 Mastered. The resulting point range should give you 95-100% stats at that point. It's absurd that stats are RANDOM. I'm Dan 3 Mastered in Magic Craft and Engie and it drives me BONKERS when the stats aren't high given all the work I put into get those up.

    6) Keep the current writer and give them a raise.

    What they said, but I'd also like to revamp the older talents/skills and give them some love :p
  • GretaGreta
    Mabinogi Rep: 51,785
    Posts: 6,975
    Member
    Easy said than done.
  • nibblesthecatnibblesthecat
    Mabinogi Rep: 1,585
    Posts: 43
    Member
    edited June 10, 2020
    1) Re-balance the Gs after 19, letting the players choose which version to play. A casual version for new players and players with bad builds who want to progress through the story but don't have the time or desire to re-rank this and that, and more intense versions for the ones who complain about it being too easy.
    2) Make it so higher level mobs count toward skill training requirements. The skill requires 100 enemies of the same level? Strong, Awful and Boss monsters count toward it.
    3) Add optional mini-plots to the dungeons. Wanna search for a missing person, find a lost thing, get involved in a botched science experiment, or investigate strange happenings instead of just running over monsters? Just pick it from a menu before you enter.
    4) Add optional DnD-style traps and curses.
    5. Make the old 'you might lose an item if you get ko'd' available as an option for those who liked that
    6. Bring back item bags for every new set to come out -- players can optionally pay $5 for the item they want instead of blowing $50 and getting nothing but training pots.
    7. Permanent size changes that don't affect proportions
    8. Every outfit fits every character without race, age or other restrictions.
    9. More races with their own stories (dwarf, gnome, hobbit, beastman, vampire, others?) and the ability to change races at rebirth.
    10. Get rid of this 'select a main character for this event' stuff
    Kalulah
  • HelsaHelsa
    Mabinogi Rep: 22,745
    Posts: 5,422
    Member
    The powers that be moved this thread here; it wasn't me.
  • YangKoeteYangKoete
    Mabinogi Rep: 3,175
    Posts: 266
    Member
    Rehaul old polygon items and slowly enhance the engine proper.
  • nomigid15nomigid15
    Mabinogi Rep: 3,720
    Posts: 233
    Member
    - Shrink the difficulty spikes, especially in the earlier Gens.

    - Buff the stat boosts for older Skills and Talents, to make single-talent specialization more viable.

    - Nerf Windmill's training requirements.
    YangKoete
  • GretaGreta
    Mabinogi Rep: 51,785
    Posts: 6,975
    Member
    Sorry gonna sound like an a-hole, but this thread is funny .
  • КалашниковКалашников
    Mabinogi Rep: 3,300
    Posts: 274
    Member
    Greta wrote: »
    Sorry gonna sound like an a-hole, but this thread is funny .

    Oh, why?
  • HelsaHelsa
    Mabinogi Rep: 22,745
    Posts: 5,422
    Member
    Greta wrote: »
    Sorry gonna sound like an a-hole, but this thread is funny .

    Oh, why?

    I can only guess, but perhaps she is amused by how modest many of the ideas presented are.
    GypsySpiritКалашников
  • HelsaHelsa
    Mabinogi Rep: 22,745
    Posts: 5,422
    Member
    Okay, my turn.

    WOT WARING!
    Most folks are of the opinion that all such games will one day be closed down. Let's say that happens to Mabinogi, what happens after that? After some time Nexon would develop another swords and sorcery type of game and the whole thing begins again. Rather than having games die and new ones made then they die and so on over and over again, why not just keep expanding the existing game. Keep updating it, modernizing it, and expanding it. One of the best loved features of Mabinogi is that there is so much you can do in it. Keeping the old girl chugging along even if it turns into some enormous chimera is only going to expand that feature even further. So, my operating principal would be like that of the old Roman Empire: keep expanding and expanding, rather than trying to squeeze as much as can be before the old girl eventually goes down.

    At first, I would complete whatever initiatives were already in the pipeline from my predecessor, then my next set of initiatives would be to ease the transition to changes in the game for players, and are as follows:
    - enable an animal transformation for humans, like beast and falcon.
    - allow giants and elves to become Paladins and Dark Knights.
    - allow Paladins and Dark Knights to switch back and forth as often as they'd like.
    - allow the Paladin/Dark Knight transformations to stack with the animal ones.
    - enable elf/giant marriage and open all venues to everyone for their ceremony.
    - remove EvG and PvDk and expand the PvP manager to allow for groups and special rules that the combatants themselves choose: such as not allowing particular skills or spamming of certain skills.
    These initiatives would then allow for the ability to change race at rebirth. Since, the Mabinogi races are different, in different situations they can not be equal. One race will always be better at PvP, one will always be better a PvE, one will always be better in groups, and so on. By allowing race change, this helps to mitigate some of the bad feelings when changes to the game effect which race is best at each of these. So, for example, if you like PvP and chose a particular race because it is best at PvP, then a rule change comes along and now a different race is better at PvP, then this strongly effects the players relationship with the game. With race change one can change to the race which is now best. This doesn't solve any aesthetic issues and would likely require a change in PvP style but it is far better than nothing and gives a player a workable option until a future change should put things back.

    After this first set of initiatives, creating a means to weather changes to the game better, we move on to what changes to make. The miracle that is Minecraft notwithstanding, when new folks see Mabinogi they inevitably ask "How old is this game?" While it is true that game play can compensate for graphics, the aforesaid Minecraft as the primary example, I would like to update the graphics quality to the current state of the art. When this has been suggested in the past some folks were concerned about the game not looking "anime" enough but more so folks with older computers were concerned about whether they could continue to play the game at all. I would have a control, perhaps in Video settings, where you could choose to display "Mabinogi Classic" or, lets call it, "Mabinogi Advanced". I'd have the PvP manager indicate which setting each combatant is using, with a button to toggle.

    Continuing, the next set of initiatives would be for expanding the capability of hosting a much larger and more widely physically distributed player-base, and are as follows:
    - replace the name/server-of-residence primary key with record number. This will allow players to use any, non-offensive, name they want, since names need not be unique. Players can have the name they actually wanted rather than a facsimile of it. We saw the issue with the merge that the requirement of name uniqueness had. This change would allow for a smooth transition to a one-server set-up. That being said, I would retain two "servers": the in-house test server partition of the database and the public partition of the database.
    - I would seek to move away from the channel system and replace it with a multi-tiered one. The first tier is the one that the log-in server shunts the user sessions to. If possible I would have these geographically distributed. Although these would be very similar to channels, the differences would be, first, that the log-in server would control where each users session is shunted and so the marshalling of the load would be kept balanced by the log-in server, and second, that the player experience would be as if they were all on the same channel. Higher tiered servers would serve the previous tier and also be distributed geographically, until we get to the highest tier. The lowest tiered servers would perform the most time-sensitive service, with services less so handled by higher tiered servers.
    - move to having one world-wide installation of the game. Either using one language, most likely English, or develop on-the-fly translation services so that all on-screen text is translated to the users local language (if possible). This service can be handled by the client.
    - since all this creates a "single channel" "single server" game, the game maps have to be reworked to be at least 9+ times bigger. I would also move to a single game-world-map with many small sectors, like how New York City is rendered in the Spider-Man games. Having the towns be much bigger and more densely populated would be cool.

    Finally, I've never seen a Nexon advertisement on TV or YouTube or really, anywhere. I see advertisements for other online games. So, I'd change that.